Manchester United Shocked by Grimsby in Carabao Cup | Amorim Admits Players Were "Lost"

Manchester United’s struggles hit a new low as Ruben Amorim’s side crashed out of the Carabao Cup to League Two outfit Grimsby after a dramatic 12-11 penalty shootout defeat.

The Premier League giants were left humiliated after an error-strewn performance that highlighted the growing cracks under Amorim’s early tenure. United fell behind 2-0 within the first half-hour and could easily have been three goals down shortly after the break.

Although Bryan Mbeumo and Harry Maguire scored late to force penalties, the Red Devils failed to capitalize in the shootout. Matheus Cunha missed the decisive spot-kick in the initial five, before the tie extended into sudden death. Eventually, Mbeumo struck the crossbar, sealing Grimsby’s famous victory and United’s embarrassing exit.

Amorim Admits “Something Has to Change”

Speaking after the defeat, manager Ruben Amorim did not hold back in his assessment of his side’s performance:

> “I think this is a little bit the limit. I think something has to change. The players spoke really loud today with how they played. Tonight, the best team won — the only team that was really on the pitch. The way we started, with no intensity, we were completely lost.”

The loss piles pressure on the Portuguese coach, who was appointed with hopes of rebuilding United’s identity and lifting morale ahead of the new campaign. Instead, optimism around Old Trafford has quickly turned into frustration, with fans voicing concerns over the lack of progress.

Grimsby’s Historic Night

For Grimsby, the victory represents one of the most memorable moments in their history, knocking out one of English football’s biggest clubs after a marathon penalty contest. The League Two side showed determination, discipline, and spirit throughout, exposing United’s lack of urgency and cohesion.

What’s Next for Manchester United?

With the Carabao Cup exit marking a painful setback, Amorim now faces urgent questions about his tactics, team selections, and ability to inspire consistent performances. The defeat also raises doubts about United’s readiness to compete on multiple fronts this season, as tougher challenges await in the Premier League and Europe.